For Sale

209 Bay Street, Oro-Medonte, Ontario L0L 2L0

$4,999,900

209 Bay Street, Oro-Medonte, Ontario L0L 2L0 is For Sale and has a listing price of 4,999,900. The property is located in the Oro-Medonte neighbourhood . It's been on the website for 6 Days.

  • Detached
    Property Type
  • 5
    Bedrooms
  • 5
    Bathrooms
  • Parking
  • MLS ID: S12386085
  • Office Name RE/MAX HALLMARK CHAY REALTY
Property Description

A rare opportunity to own a true waterfront retreat in the heart of Shanty Bay. Set on a quiet, dead-end street, this exceptional lakefront property offers almost 200 feet of south-facing shoreline with crystal-clear, deep waterperfect for swimming, boating, and soaking in panoramic views across Kempenfelt Bay. Set on a beautifully treed, private lot, this estate includes a main cottage, guest house, and a bunkie above the garagetotalling 12 bedrooms, 8 bathrooms, and 3 kitchens. Whether you’re hosting extended family, entertaining guests, or exploring rental income, theres space for everyone. Enjoy unobstructed lake views from most principal rooms, and step outside to a host of outdoor features including: a Private concrete waterfront patio, a Marine railway with covered boat slip and an Expansive rooftop deck above the boat slipperfect for sunset entertaining. The main cottage exudes warmth and character, featuring wood floors, a charming stone fireplace, a Muskoka room with stunning views, and a cozy third-level loft. Additional highlights include: a Heated garage with bunkie above, Parking for 10+ vehicles, Secluded and a park-like setting with mature trees for total privacy. All this just 10 minutes to Barrie, Royal Victoria Hospital, shops, and servicesplus an easy 1-hour drive to Toronto. Enjoy quick boat access to Friday Harbours dining and amenities, and explore nearby Simcoe Loop Trail for walking and cycling. Whether you enjoy this special property as-is or explore its future severance or redevelopment potential, this is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to own a legacy lakefront estate in one of Lake Simcoes most desirable communities.

Property Details
  • Property Type: All Houses
  • Listing Type: For Sale
  • Listing ID: S12386085
  • Price: $4,999,900
  • Year Built: 0
  • Lot Area: 0 Sqft
  • Lot Depth: 156
  • Ref ID: S12386085
  • Approx Sqft: 3000-3500
  • Dir / Cross St: Ridge/Line 2
  • Status: Active
  • Tax Year: 2024
  • Property Type: Detached
  • Property Sub Category: Detached
Price History
List Date MLS ID List Price Status End Date Closed Price
09/06/2025 S12386085 $4,999,900 For Sale - -
03/05/2025 S12002759 $4,999,900 For Sale -
08/09/2024 S9247622 $5,490,900 Expired -
Market Temperature
  • Buyer's Market
  • Balanced
  • Seller's Market
Neighborhood Stats
Oro-Medonte
  • $1,275,858 Average List Price
    based on 1 year
  • 158 New Listings
    based on 30 days
  • 78 Median Days on Market
    based on 1 year
  • List vs. Selling Price 186.77 % Up
  • Sold (12mo) 281
  • Rented (12mo) 22

  • 1 Month Change +124.3%
  • 3 Month Change +38.2%
  • 6 Month Change +70.0%
Walkscore
Property Type Distribution
  • All Houses
    76.67%
  • All Houses/Commercial
    0.05%
  • Commercial
    13.22%
  • Condo
    8.8%
  • Land for Sale
    1.27%
Additional Details
  • Heat Type Forced Air
  • Heat Source Gas
  • Style 2-storey
  • Washroom Type1: 1
  • Garage Type Detached
  • Parking Spaces: 10
  • Exterior Vinyl Siding
  • Kitchen Y
  • Fireplace Y
  • Parking Y
  • Family Room: 1
  • Washrooms Type 1 # Pcs: 2
  • Washrooms Type 2 # Pcs: 5
  • Washrooms Type 3 # Pcs: 1
  • Washrooms Type 4 # Pcs: 3
  • Washrooms Type 5 # Pcs: 3
  • Washrooms Type 2: 1
  • Washrooms Type 3: 1
  • Washrooms Type 4: 1
  • Washrooms Type 5: 1
  • Taxes: $14,417
  • Last Status New
  • Original Price: $0
  • Sold Price: $0
  • Addl Monthly Fees: $0
  • Listing Entry Date: 06/09/2025 13:37:57
Want to see this property?